Confident Representation In Personal Injury And Insurance Claim Cases

What do you need to prove a bad faith insurance claim?

On Behalf of | Jan 16, 2024 | Insurance Bad Faith

In the insurance sector, policyholders generally trust that their insurers will act in good faith and honor their commitments in times of need. Unfortunately, not all insurance companies uphold these principles, leading to instances of bad faith insurance conduct.

Bad faith can be defined as the breaching of a contract between an insurance company and a policyholder. Bad faith can also extend to breaching the implied agreement of fair dealing. If you believe that you’ve been a victim of bad faith practices, you’ll generally have to prove that your insurer breached an existing contract to win a bad faith lawsuit.

Documentation and evidence

In any legal battle, documentation is key. Therefore, you should keep thorough records of all communication with your insurance company, including emails, letters and phone calls. These records can serve as crucial evidence to support your claim of bad faith.

Beyond communication records, gather any relevant documents that can strengthen your case. This may include medical bills, repair estimates and photographs of damages—the more comprehensive your evidence is, the more compelling your argument against bad faith may be.

Submitting a written complaint to your insurance company is another essential step in the process. Clearly outline the details of your claim, emphasizing any instances where bad faith may have occurred. Be specific and provide supporting documentation to help strengthen your case.

Navigating the claims process

Familiarize yourself with the typical claims process of your insurance company. Enlisting legal help at this stage can better help you identify deviations from standard procedures that may indicate bad faith practices.

Insurers are generally expected to handle claims promptly and fairly, and any deviation from this norm may be a red flag. In cases of dispute, obtaining an independent assessment of your claim can provide an unbiased evaluation. This third-party opinion can carry significant weight in establishing bad faith, especially if it contradicts the insurer’s assessment.

If all else fails, filing a lawsuit against your insurance company may be a necessary step in seeking justice. In successful bad faith insurance cases, policyholders may be entitled to various remedies, including compensatory damages, punitive damages and attorney fees. Understanding the potential outcomes can help you set realistic expectations for your case.

Proving bad faith insurance requires a combination of vigilance, documentation and legal strategy. By understanding the signs of bad faith, maintaining detailed records, employing effective communication strategies and seeking legal recourse, policyholders can strengthen their position and potentially hold insurance companies accountable for wrongdoing.